Plausible deniability

File 09 / 12

Smoking Gun

The one conviction-grade clue. Earn it, block it, or miss it entirely.

One clue that convicts

The Smoking Gun is the game’s single conviction-grade clue. It can’t be planted and it can’t be faked. It can only be earned — or blocked.

Three possible outcomes

Earned The ceremony reveals it

The Blue track hit its milestone. The gun does the heavy lifting at accusation.

Blocked Five Reds banked

The blocked script reads instead — the easy win is gone.

Skipped Neither side got close

The ceremony passes quietly. Nobody’s told what they missed.

If the gun is blocked

A conviction alone isn’t enough at the end — you must also prove Motive. See Winning.

Follow the journey

Get on the guestlist.

Want to know what we’re plotting next? Join the club for exclusive developer diaries, progress reports of upcoming features, and a front-row seat as we create this game. Plus, get early access to Guilty Party and be the first to turn your friend group into a crime scene.